I stumbled across one of the oldest discussions among PC simulator pilots and real professionals. The question is: could a PC simulator pilot land an airliner, after the entire crew was taken out by that famous fish poisoning?
I found a lot of familiar arguments, some of which I used myself a while ago. I believed that I could land an airliner based on my (extensive) simulator practice.
Before I could (finally!) get going on my own license, I had some 2000 hours on different PC flight simulators. More than 1000 of those were collected online on IVAO, accumulated in the 2 years before I could afford* the PPL. Many real pilots underestimate what you can get out of PC flight simulators, especially online. The amount of experiences and knowledge is gigantic - but it is over-estimated by most PC flight simulator enthusiasts. I was no different.
I started flying on the simulator just like real pilots do: first the flight training in the Cessna 172, after that the first twin engine (Beech Baron 58, what else?), after that the first jet. But it really started with online flight simulation: voice radio, IFR procedures, bigger and more complicated aircraft. I never liked the big airliners much, but I loved the Dash8 - a relatively small type. I had a couple of hours in a quite elaborate 737, but my computer couldn't lift the PMDG, the supposedly most realistic aircraft for flightsim on the market.
At that time, I knew the Dash8 inside out. I even compared the panel to the real thing on a few flights between Vienna and Friedrichshafen - and was surprised about the accuracy. Everything matched, even the *ding* sound 1000ft before leveling off sounded exactly the same. I believe to this day that I probably could get the Dash8 autopilot to do what I want it to do (that thing can be a bitch). Back then, I even thought that I would have been able to do that fish poisoning landing - with damages to the aircraft, probably, but without casualties.
Soon after that came my first full time job, thereafter I began to fulfill my dream: fly myself, for real. With 2000 simulator hours and voice experience under my belt (voice was, thanks to online simulation, really no problem. I still have to smile when I remember the faces of the board of examiners) I thought that most of the training would be a formality. After all, a Cessna 172 is by far less complicated than my Dash. I did some extra hours on the Cessna just to make sure. Voice, navigation, technical details like MTOW and airspeeds etc. were there, ground school didn't teach me much I didn't already know. I basically was a pilot without a license.
Then came that darned, first flying lesson.
It began with the simple fact that it is pointless to use the ailerons to taxi around a turn on ground - the aircraft will continue to go straight ahead, pig-headed as it is. Of course I knew that I had to use the rudder controls, but I never used pedals on my PC and was just used to use my hands to steer on ground. Against better knowledge, I turned my "steering wheel" following my intuition - no effect (besides the wide grin on the face of my flight instructor). Some of the PC simmers out there will argue that they do, in fact, use a yoke, rudder pedals and god knows what other fancy hardware for their professional flight simulations, and they probably would not have made this mistake.
But that is by no way everything there is to it - there is a fundamental principle: in a real aircraft, the simplest operations do not go automatically if they were not trained in a real aircraft before. Need an example? Turn on your carburetor heating on your PC. And now lift your hand if you used an actual physical switch to do that. Where is that switch in a real aircraft? Do you have to pull it up, down, inwards or outwards? Do you have to unlock it before you can use it? Thinking about that alone takes away some precious seconds from your time. Now, is that sudden change in the sound of the engine supposed to be that rough? Quickly check the rev meter... drats, where is that? (tick tack...) Seems to be OK. But wasn't there something about the mixture? Why is that red lever stuck? (tick tack tick tack...)
And it continues like that. Primitive operations that were absolutely no problem on your PC, suddenly require your full attention. And the things that really need that attention get less of it, stress begins to pile up. And now the aircraft is flying the pilot instead of the other way around.
But back to my first flight lesson.
I'm taxiing around that turn, with deflected ailerons and rudder, until I am more or less aligned to the runway center line. Cleared for takeoff, full throttle - the p-effect does not come as a surprise, and I manage to stay at least in the vicinity of the runway centerline on the takeoff run. Rotate, liftoff - the aircraft wants to bank to the left immediately, I'm correcting and remain a horizontal wing attitude. The right hand remains on the throttle lever. I loose some airspeed, have to push the nose down a bit - this requires some strength in my left arm, surprisingly much. There comes a wind blow, and the aircraft wants to bank to the right - I correct, remain horizontal - no Problem. Airspeed, vertical speed? Smooth. Then the FI asks me where the heck I'm going, and corrects the course 20 degrees to the right.
It took no more than 5 seconds after leaving the ground, and I didn't fly on runway heading any more. I did not notice it in that situation, but all that I could see was only what I had right in front of my nose, I never looked left or right. Tunnel vision. The ground in front disappeared below the cowling, I lost my visual orientation points, and thus my orientation and flight direction.
Just after that comes the right turn for the departure procedure, I am totally occupied with a stable attitude. 20 seconds later I look outside the window and have absolutely no idea where the heck I am, which direction I am going and where the airfield is. The compass shows a big E, so I'm going eastwards - totally useless information if you don't know where you are. It could as well have told me that a bag of rice in china was dropped to the floor. TOTAL loss of orientation. The geography looks entirely different from above than it does on ground, the orientation points you were used to are worthless. I passed a large shopping mall and a McDonalds on my drive to the airport, I should find them down there somewhere...
My FI tells me to steer towards that power transformer station in front of us. What, there's a transformer station around here? I look and look, no transformer anywhere. How is that supposed to look anyway, and from above? Of course, when you fly your fish poisoned airliner, you use your instruments and your FMC to navigate, and we all know that this is a lot easier than just looking outside the window, don't we.
The actual experience to sit in an aircraft and steer it is so fundamentally different from any flight simulation that I could not even make the airfield as we arrived, and only after the nose of the aircraft was pointing straight to the runway I was able to see it. I just experienced the same effect the other day, on a local sightseeing flight around lake constance. Big lake, impossible to miss, the perfect landmark for orientation. Nonetheless, my passengers told me that they had absolutely no idea where they are. If you're not used to it, you have absolutely no chance to maintain spacial orientation once airborne. An other lesson I could not learn from my PC, despite 2000 hours.
You get as much from your PC flight simulation as you put into it. For many simulator pilots, that is an extremely huge amount of information and experience, but it is by no ways complete and never can be. It is like learning the recipe for a menu by heart, without ever practicing how to cook. Lets suppose there was a cooking simulation where you smash the eggs by clicking on them repeatedly with your mouse. In reality one needs a good portion of dexterity and caution, and unless you're interested in having egg shell with your omelet, you'll need some practice as well. In that respect, cooking is no different than flying - you need some practice to do it right. I can throw away a burned omelet, but I cannot do that with my life.
By now I know how perilous and life threatening my PC flight simulation based half-knowledge about aviation would have been for me, if I had to steer that Cessna without a flight instructor on the right seat. The flight simulator helped me a lot in many respects, but it did not replace flight training.
I now wouldn't trust myself with that Dash8 landing any longer, because I know more about flying than I did a few years ago. Because of my experiences, not despite them.
*) Footnote: I couldn't really afford the PPL, I think noone without vast amounts of spare change can. But like many pilots, I refused to accept that as a fact, and by some mysterious way it just worked out.

No comments:
Post a Comment